Why Didn’t the Chinese Stock Market Go Up Like the GDP

China’s economy has been booming in the last 40 years like a miracle. Reflecting on the GDP chart as below comparing to other big economic bodies:

Even US’s GDP is leading far ahead but the acceleration rate is clearly smaller than China and in no time, China’s GDP will surpass the United States’.

Along the way, Chinese people’s income also grow rapidly. However, what’s interesting to observe is that the Real Estate market and stock market are growing in very dis-proportionally pace with clear bubble in over heated RE market, while stock market relatively flat in last 40 some years. Why so?

There are multiple version of answers on Quora, but I think it has to be viewed and interpreted from the uniqueness of China, which essentially is not a true capitalism but one party enforcing a capitalism like game.

I filtered out the top 10 companies listed in Shenzhen (SHE), Shanghai(SHG) and Hongkong(HKG) markets.

Shengzhen market is sort of like Nasdaq, with more Consumer, Technology, Industrials in the bucket. The highest is alcohol producer Wuliangye with the market value at below $200B size.

Shanghai market which is established earlier than Shenzhen, supposedly listing lots of state-owned companies. Other than the top Maotai company, the rest are dominated by banks, insurance, security, construction companies. The market size of Maotai is on a higher scale above $300 billion while the rest are on par with those at SHE. This is well expected because large amount of profits are reaped by the government selling land, then building infrastructure, meanwhile, currency is locked from free trading, hence trillions of dollars are stored by the treasury, while massive amount of RMB is out and counted in banks, insurance, securities, infrastructure companies.

So where are the rapidly growing internet tech companies? They went abroad. Mammoth in Hongkong stock exchange are as below table, clearly Chinese companies are dominant. High tech Alibaba, Tencent are among them, and what’s more, the scale of them are 3-fold than that of domestic market, with Alibaba and Tencent listed at over $600 Billion.

I would also like to take a look at Chinese ADRs. There are over 40 such ADRs with Pinduoduo leading the race, sizing significantly smaller than Tencent and Alibaba yet (1/10) at $57 billion. But there is huge potential to grow.

Overall, in the past years, Chinese stock market is less favored by local investors due to government’s directing capital to RE and lots of capital depositing at banks energy companies, that normal investors are not able to really share the growth, on the other hand, stellar companies went abroad listing in HKG and American market, so the growth were gleaned by foreign investors.

However looking forward, the capital will move back to stock market, good companies such as Pingduoduo or Alibaba Xiaomi Nio listed off shore will keep growing. That’s why Ray Dalio is deploying big betting on both Chinese and American markets. His positions on the following ETFs reflects his view of world-wide economic prospect.

VWO – Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF
VEA – Vanguard FTSE Developed Markets ETF
EFA – iShares MSCI EFAE ETF

MCHI – iShares MSCI China ETF
FXI – iShares China Large-Cap ETF

IAU – iShares Gold Trust ETF

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.